Benjamin Carpenter BJJ Black Belt Charged With First-Degree Intentional Homicide in Wife’s 2024 Death

Benjamin Carpenter BJJ Black Belt Charged With First-Degree Intentional Homicide in Wife's 2024 Death

  • Benjamin Carpenter BJJ black belt was arrested and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in the October 2024 death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, in West Allis, Wisconsin.
  • Prosecutors frame a choke — the sport’s most basic submission — as the alleged murder weapon, citing asphyxia findings and a black belt’s own words about chokeholds.
  • The medical examiner’s final cause of death was “undetermined,” but findings point to asphyxia, a blunt-force neck injury, and a brain injury from lack of oxygen.
  • Carpenter is being held on $500,000 bond, and the case rests largely on circumstantial evidence.

West Allis, Wisconsin — A Milwaukee-area Jiu-Jitsu black belt now sits at the center of a first-degree intentional homicide prosecution, nearly two years after his wife was found unresponsive at the bottom of their basement stairs.

Benjamin A. Carpenter, 45, was arrested on the morning of Nov. 17, 2026, and charged with one count of first-degree intentional homicide in the October 2024 death of Erica A. Carpenter, 40. At the heart of the 17-page criminal complaint is Carpenter’s own grappling background — and what prosecutors say a trained black belt knows about chokes.

The Arrest and the Charge

West Allis police took Carpenter into custody the morning of Tuesday, Nov. 17, after a warrant was issued. The Milwaukee County District Attorney’s Office filed the first-degree intentional homicide charge that same day, roughly two years after the investigation began. Neighbors told local reporters they had seen Carpenter as recently as the weekend before his arrest. If convicted, he faces life in prison.

The October 2024 Death and the Initial Account

The case begins on Oct. 13, 2024, when West Allis police were dispatched around 10:30 p.m. for a welfare check at a home in the 2900 block of South 95th Street. Officers found Erica Carpenter bleeding from her head at the bottom of the basement stairs, with her husband performing CPR. Erica was taken to a hospital and pronounced dead the next morning, Oct. 14, 2024, at approximately 5:14 a.m.

According to the criminal complaint, Carpenter told police his wife had not been feeling well and collapsed while the two were doing laundry in the basement. He said that as he carried her up the stairs, he slipped and they both fell, and she struck her head. Investigators later said the account shifted across retellings — in one version he said he fell on top of her, and in another that she was awake and had caught herself.

Octopus Guard by Craig Jones

“One of the firefighters indicated Benjamin Carpenter appeared more upset about how he was being asked questions by both police and fire than he was about the CPR being performed on his wife or the fact she was dying.”
–From the criminal complaint –

The Medical Evidence: “Undetermined” Cause, Asphyxia, and a Neck Injury

The Milwaukee County Medical Examiner’s Office ruled Erica Carpenter’s final cause of death undetermined — a finding her family has said troubled them. But the autopsy findings laid out in the complaint are what prosecutors point to: a brain injury from a lack of oxygen, blunt-force trauma to her head and neck, and several drugs in her system.

The deputy chief medical examiner said the death may have resulted from asphyxia and indicated a blunt-force neck injury, and court documents describe the death as “highly suspicious and concerning for a death resulting from asphyxia.” A toxicology report found four drugs, including hydrocodone, an opioid pain medication, and doxylamine, a short-term sleep aid.

Why the Black Belt Matters: The Choke in the Benjamin Carpenter BJJ Complaint

This is where the sport becomes central to probable cause. The complaint references Carpenter’s background as a black belt in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu and his familiarity with the choke submission move.

When investigators asked about his training, Carpenter said he held a black belt in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu and that chokeholds can cause someone to pass out — adding, according to the complaint, that he did not believe they typically leave significant marks on the person they are applied to.

The reported complaint language stops short of naming a specific technique, referring instead to chokeholds and the choke submission move. In Jiu-Jitsu terms, the rear-naked choke is the sport’s signature blood choke — the kind of hold that puts a person out in seconds and can leave little visible bruising.

The complaint also cites Carpenter’s Roufus Sport profile, which lists competition history from 2010 through 2016 across US Grappling, NAGA, IBJJF, and Grappling Industries events, culminating in his advancement to black belt. Nothing in the documents alleges he currently teaches there.

What the Investigation Allegedly Found

Beyond the medical findings, the complaint lays out what investigators describe as a pattern. Police allege Carpenter was in a relationship with another woman, identified in court documents only by initials, and had told her he planned to divorce his wife; the woman said she would end the relationship if he was still married.

Text messages recovered by investigators show Erica questioning her husband roughly a month before her death about a powdery substance in her water.

“And what the [expletive] have you been doing to my water the past few days?!?!?”
– Text message from Erica Carpenter to Benjamin Carpenter, cited in the criminal complaint –

Investigators also point to searches on Carpenter’s phone: in September 2024, phrases such as “losing someone” and “watching someone you love die,” and, on Oct. 13, 2024 — the day of the welfare check — “can I crush pills and take them in water.”

After his wife’s death, authorities allege, Carpenter collected more than $200,000 from a life insurance policy and her employment benefits, and spent more than $3,750 on a diamond bracelet three days after her funeral.

The 2025 Strangulation Allegation and Later Domestic Incidents

Erica Carpenter’s death is not the only allegation of violence against a woman tied to the case. According to police statements reported by local news, in 2025 officers returned to the same West Allis home after Carpenter’s girlfriend said he tried to strangle her; months later, police were called again for another domestic-abuse report involving the pair.

Court records describe an October 2025 case in which Carpenter was accused of striking the woman he was dating — charging documents state she had bruising and swelling around her eyes and told an Uber driver that “if she dies it was him who did it.” Carpenter later pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor in that case, and again the following month to violating a no-contact order.

Where the Case Stands

The Benjamin Carpenter BJJ case now moves toward a preliminary hearing and, if it proceeds, a trial built largely on circumstantial evidence. Carpenter made his first court appearance Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2026, before Milwaukee County Court Commissioner Rosa Barillas, who referenced the investigation detailed in the complaint. Court records show he is being held on $500,000 bond, with a return to court set for next month.

For Erica’s parents, Debra and Michael Clarenbach, the charges have reopened a wound that was only beginning to heal.

“Completely blindsided… That it seemed like Ben had a dark side that we didn’t know about.”
– Michael Clarenbach, Erica Carpenter’s father –

No response from an attorney was located by deadline; an attorney declined to comment when reached, according to local reporting. Carpenter is charged, not convicted, and every allegation remains to be proven in court.

FREE Gordon Ryan Instructional
Wiltse Free Instructional
Previous articleCow Catchers & Guillotines Brandon Quick DVD Review [2026]